Recently I came across a book. I had heard about it from a friend that it had *some* good in it. It is called “To Train Up a Child” by Mike and Debi Pearl. Unfortunately, as soon as I found out more about the book I realized that this kind of literature is dangerous for parents.
Now, just as a disclaimer, if you have read the book and found pieces of it you liked, that’s ok. But having read the book (there is a copy online where you can read it in entirety) I found the bad strongly outweighed the good. If you liked the book, that’s not a judgement on you as a parent.I’m sure that many good parents have read the book and liked it. I’m just telling you how that book made me feel.
The whole premise of “To Train Up a Child” in the first chapter is to get your child to do whatever you want him to do on command from the time they are around 10 months old. Unfortunately, most 10 month olds don’t understand commands, apparently that plagues the Pearls because they believe a 10 month old has the comprehensive capability of a 4 year old. The opening of the book differentiates between “good” children and “bad” children. “Good” children, according to the Pearls, leave mommy and daddy alone for 2 hours straight and mind their own business, unless they need to go to the bathroom. “Bad” children stay around their parents and don’t want to leave and whine (all normal things for a young toddler to do, which in this case Mike Pearl is referring to).
Truthfully, I wouldn’t want my daughter to just leave me alone for 2 hours straight. I think it’d be kind of strange if she did, it would probably show a lack of attachment in our relationship. What parent doesn’t want to be with their young child and what young child doesn’t want to be with their parent? God has given a mother and an infant a natural bond and attachment. To discourage that bond and to force the child away from the mother is unnatural.
Apparently, also according to the Pearls, your young toddler should be able to sit still in church for the length of an entire sermon and not say peep. Now there may be some toddlers out there who are capable of doing this, but many, including my daughter, are not. That is why most churches have nurseries because they know it’s unreasonable to expect a 1-3 year old to be able to sit still throughout an entire sermon and not make a fuss. There is no reason to punish your child for getting antsy in a sermon if he or she is not of the age where he can really control himself very well.
Another thing I found disturbing was the usage of spanking on babies that refuse to go to sleep. Babies don’t refuse to go to sleep because they are being disobedient or rebellious, they refuse to go to sleep because they can’t yet get themselves to fall asleep on their own. The Pearls advocate spanking a baby who gets up when placed in his crib. They advocate spanking the poor infant until he learns to lie still in his crib. Excuse me but, what kind of cruelty is this? Infants do this, not out of rebellion, but because they are frustrated that they can’t put themselves to sleep. Scaring your poor child into sleeping isn’t going to make them sleep any better and it isn’t going to build or nurture the relationship between parent and child.
Another disturbing motto of the Pearls is “Don’t babyproof your house, houseproof your baby”. Hello? Don’t you know that infants and young toddlers are curious little beings? Don’t you know that their instinct is to explore and investigate their surroundings? How then can you expect a young infant to not try to grab at what is in plain sight? Now, I do believe that you should use NO if you are at someone else’s house and they are trying to grab something they shouldn’t. Yet at your house it is a different environment. Children must have their boundaries, they must have their places they can explore and be safe. If everything is a NO then there is no fun and there is no exploration. There will always be NOs, regardless if you babyproof or not. However, if you don’t at least attempt to childproof, all you will be saying is NO NO NO.
I just found the book very saddening in that it seems like the Pearls do not much like children. I just don’t understand why a family would want to have a child if all they did was send the child to another room for hours on end while they do whatever they want. Children should be loved and appreciated by parents. We should nurture their spirits and encourage their curiousity while still offering limits and boundaries to how far they can go. Yes we need to discipline children in a sensible manner, but we also need to let them be children. After all, children are only children for a short while, they are adults for a much longer period of time.
Today I saw my daughter gleefully dancing and spinning to music. She is such a joyful little being. I celebrate the fact that God made her antsy at times, very active, and very talklative. She is so enjoyable and fun. I am grateful to God for the fact that my daughter does not want to leave my side for 2 hours straight, that she rejoices when I return from going to the grocery store, that we have such a beautiful relationship.
Yea, she may not be a “good” child in the eyes of the Pearls, but she is every bit of a blessing to me.